From my kitchen to your family table

Your favorite nostalgic treats, made cleaner & sourdough.

Remember the comforting tastes of childhood — warm toaster pastries, soft sandwich bread that made the perfect PB&J, and sweet cinnamon rolls on Saturday mornings? Here in Merrick, we slow things down: 36-hour wild sourdough fermentation, organic flours, grass-fed butter, and real fruit. Nostalgic comfort, without the seed oils, preservatives, or belly bloat.

• 36-Hour Wild Ferment • Organic NY & King Arthur Flours • Gentle on Digestion
Artisan sourdough loaf and buttermilk sandwich bread on floured table
Freshly Baked Every Weekend
Small-batch porch pickup in Merrick, NY
Order Bakes →

36-Hour Cold Patience

We never use commercial fast yeast or chemical dough conditioners. Our loaves cold-ferment for up to 36 hours, naturally breaking down gluten and phytic acid so bread is kind to your stomach.

Nostalgia Made Honest

We love childhood comfort food, but grocery store versions are full of high-fructose corn syrup and palm oil. We handcraft them with pasture butter, real organic fruits, and flaky sourdough pastry.

Small-Batch Micro-Bakery

Baked in small, intentional batches in Nicole’s home kitchen. Pulled warm from the oven on Friday and Saturday mornings, ready for local Merrick porch pickup.

Sliced Buttermilk Sourdough Sandwich Loaf with melting butter
Nicole’s Signature Bake

A Little Love for the Buttermilk Sourdough

“Soft inside with a golden crust and that little sourdough tang we love!”

Most artisan sourdough loaves have a thick, crunchy crust that young children find tough to chew for everyday sandwiches. We solved that by folding cultured whole buttermilk directly into our wild-fermented dough. The lactic acids yield a cloud-soft, tender crumb that squishes just right for peanut butter and honey, yet toasts to golden perfection for Sunday morning grilled cheese.

36 Hours Cold Ferment
Whole Buttermilk Pillowy Crumb
$12.00 Fresh Loaf
Kitchen Gatherings

Bake Sourdough Around Nicole’s Table

Sourdough can feel intimidating when you are reading contradictory guides online. In these intimate, hands-on masterclasses (strictly limited to 8 bakers), Nicole walks you through every step in her sunny Merrick kitchen. You’ll touch the dough, learn tension shaping, understand fermentation timing, and leave with your own banneton of proofed dough to bake at home.

✓ Includes active jar of Nicole’s 4-year starter "Mabel" ✓ Cane banneton proofing basket & scoring razor included ✓ Warm sourdough tasting lunch with compound butters
Hands-on sourdough bread making workshop in Nicole's kitchen
A Note from Nicole

Why We Slow Down for 36 Patient Hours

In the 1960s, commercial breadmaking made a drastic turn toward speed. Fast-rising chemical yeast replaced patient fermentation, allowing industrial factories to turn wheat flour into bagged loaves in 90 minutes flat. But speed came at a steep cost: our digestive systems never had time to handle the unfermented proteins and anti-nutrients.

When flour and water mingle with wild lactobacillus bacteria over 24 to 36 hours of cold fermentation, something miraculous happens: the bacteria pre-digest complex gluten peptide bonds, break down phytic acid (which normally blocks mineral absorption), and lower the glycemic index of the grain.

Gentle on the Belly

Many of our neighbors with non-celiac gluten sensitivity tell us they can eat our sourdough every single day without the bloating or heaviness of store bread.

No Seed Oils or Chemical Relaxers

We use exclusively grass-fed European cultured butter, extra virgin olive oil, and organic flours. You will never find soybean oil, high-fructose corn syrup, or artificial food dyes in our kitchen.

It takes us three days to make each batch of bread and toaster pastries. It is more work, but when you share a slice with your family on a Sunday morning, you can taste the patience and honest love in every bite.

Nicole Crites
Mama & Baker • Merrick, NY
Reserve Your Weekend Loaf →
Nicole holding a warm loaf of fresh sourdough bread in her home kitchen
The Baker’s Story

“Made by a mama, for your family.”

Hi, I’m Nicole! Merrick Mama Bakes grew out of my desire to feed my own kids real, nourishing food. Standing in grocery store aisles reading long ingredient lists full of unpronounceable stabilizers and synthetic dough conditioners made me realize how far modern bread had drifted from genuine food.

I missed the nostalgic comfort treats of growing up — warm cinnamon rolls, golden sandwich bread, and toaster pastries — but I wanted them made with ingredients I could be proud of. Four years ago, my sourdough starter “Mabel” was born. What started as weekend baking for my family quickly turned into neighbors knocking on our door asking for loaves.

When you pick up a warm paper bag from our porch in Merrick, you are getting food made with the exact same care and uncompromised ingredients I feed my own children. Thank you for welcoming our bakes to your family table.

Join Our Facebook Community (250+ Neighbors)
Porch Pickup in Merrick, NY

How the Weekly Bake Works

Because true wild sourdough takes 36 hours of patient fermentation, we bake to order every week.

1

Monday – Wednesday

Weekly bake drops open online. Browse treats and reserve your order.

2

Wednesday at 6:00 PM

Order cutoff. Nicole feeds "Mabel" and begins mixing the weekend doughs.

3

Friday (2 PM – 6 PM) & Saturday (9 AM – 1 PM)

Baked fresh at sunrise and packaged in paper bags on our shaded porch in Merrick, NY.

Porch Location & Payment

Our porch pickup is located on a quiet residential street in Merrick, Long Island (11566). You will receive the exact street address upon reservation.

As a boutique home cottage bakery, payment is collected conveniently via Venmo (@Nicole-Crites), Zelle, or cash in our porch drop-box at pickup.

Reserve This Weekend’s Bakes
Local Love

From Merrick Families

“The Buttermilk Sourdough has replaced grocery store bread in our house forever. My toddler devours it with butter, and knowing there's zero seed oils gives me so much peace of mind.”

Jessica M. • Merrick, NY

“Her strawberry toaster pastries made me so nostalgic! Flaky, buttery, real fruit flavor, and none of that artificial chemical sweetness from the supermarket boxes.”

Danielle K. • Bellmore, NY

“I took Nicole's beginner sourdough workshop and it was worth every penny. She made the whole starter process so friendly and approachable. We now have warm bread every Saturday!”

Rachel S. • Wantagh, NY